☰Menu
O Santuário Geek

What is SBMM and how Call of Duty builds matches

SBMM decides who you face in Call of Duty. See exactly how the game builds each lobby, what the queue weighs and why the debate has flared up again.

Add as a preferred source on GoogleWhatsAppTelegram

Share this article

Three armed Modern Warfare 4 operators advance down a dark street beside the game logo
Official art for Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4, which arrived on October 23 with Classic Matchmaking across every multiplayer mode. · Photo: Courtesy of Activision

SBMM — short for skill-based matchmaking — is the system that decides who you play against in Call of Duty. Every match, it estimates your level from recent performance, compares that rating with other players in the queue and builds a lobby of similar ability. The topic returned to the center of the debate on November 13, 2026, when Mark Rubin, a producer on Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare and Modern Warfare 2, publicly criticized the model. The frustration gained weight because Modern Warfare 4, released on October 23, shipped without an open playlist and with Classic Matchmaking — the stricter version of the system — across every multiplayer mode.

This explainer covers what SBMM does, what it does not do, how the game builds each match in practice and why criticism from a developer who no longer works on the franchise revived an argument almost a decade old.

What SBMM is, in one sentence

SBMM stands for skill-based matchmaking: a set of rules that uses an ability estimate to bring players of similar level together in public matches. That estimate is usually called MMR (matchmaking rating), a hidden score the player never sees — unlike the Bronze, Silver or Gold ranks of competitive play.

The key point is that SBMM is not an on/off switch, and it is not an algorithm that decides you will lose the next match. It is a seat allocator: it takes a list of available players, a set of constraints (server, wait time, party size) and returns two teams. The quality of the result depends on how many people are in the queue at that minute, the time of day and the mode you picked.

How the game builds a match, step by step

Activision does not publish the exact formula, but it outlines the process in its technical matchmaking reports. In order of priority, it works like this:

  1. Estimate skill. The system calculates a rating from recent results — kills, deaths, wins, score per minute — and updates that rating after every match.
  2. Filter by connection. The company repeats that “ping is king”: the first sieve looks for players on servers with acceptable latency for you.
  3. Respect wait time. The longer the queue runs, the wider the system stretches the acceptable skill band so you are not left sitting in the menu.
  4. Weigh the context. Party size, playlist, platform, crossplay and available population all change the calculation.
  5. Assemble the lobby. Players are grouped into a similar MMR band.
  6. Split the teams. Only then is the lobby divided into two sides, trying to avoid blowouts — that is team balancing, a separate step from SBMM.

An illustrative example helps. Picture a player with an internal rating of 1,200 on a fictional 0–2,000 scale. The game does not look for eleven people at exactly 1,200; it searches a nearby window, such as 1,100 to 1,300, and inside that window it favors the server with the best ping. If the queue is empty at 4 a.m., the window opens to 1,000–1,450. The resulting lobby can have similar averages and still contain one player far above the general level next to two below it — which explains matches that feel lopsided even with SBMM active.

What goes into the calculation

Factor Practical weight Effect on your lobby
Connection (ping)The highest, according to ActivisionAccepts a skill gap to avoid lag
Wait timeSecond highestA long queue widens the skill band
Skill (MMR)High, but not exclusiveBrings opponents closer to your recent level
Team balanceHighTries to avoid one-sided scores inside the same lobby
Population and time of dayVariableFewer players online means more mixed matches
PartyVariableMixed groups pull the average and distort the outcome
Ranked modeIts own rulesUses a visible rank and is not the same as public SBMM

Why every lobby feels like a CDL final

The most repeated complaint is the feeling that every match is decisive. SBMM produces that effect on purpose: if you play well, your rating rises, and the game starts putting stronger opponents in front of you. The result is a win rate that tends to settle near 50% — which, for someone who is improving, feels like standing still.

The second effect is pressure on your loadout. Because the lobby's average level rises with you, trying a weapon outside the meta costs you. It is the same mechanism that explains why the six weapons dominating the Modern Warfare 4 tier list show up in almost every match: the system does not force anyone into the meta, but it punishes those who take a risk.

“SBMM makes it the most miserable experience to date… kill, die, repeat forever,” one player wrote on X on October 23, in a post quoted by Dexerto. The line became a summary of how part of the community feels, but it describes a perception — not proof of manipulation.

SBMM is not EOMM: where data ends and theory begins

Much of the distrust comes from another concept, EOMM (engagement optimized matchmaking), which would tune matches to keep you playing rather than to make them fair. The idea traces back to a 2017 academic paper by researchers linked to EA, which tested the proposal in simulation — not in a live game.

A 2015 Activision patent, granted in 2017, also circulates: it describes matchmaking systems capable of encouraging purchases. The company said at the time that the filing was exploratory and was never implemented. To this day there is no public evidence that Call of Duty hands out scripted wins or losses.

What does exist is a stated justification. Activision argues that keeping skill in the calculation reduces blowouts and quitting. In a 2024 experiment, the company loosened the skill weight for half of the North American audience and reported more quits, especially among low- and medium-skill players. The conclusion is debatable, but the data is the company's own — and it does not support the idea of purchased matches.

What Mark Rubin said — and what he proposes

Mark Rubin spent about a decade at Infinity Ward, where he was a producer on Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare and the original Modern Warfare 2, then executive producer on Modern Warfare 3 and Ghosts. Later he held the same role on XDefiant, the Ubisoft shooter known precisely for keeping SBMM to a minimum.

𝕏
Mark Rubin (@PixelsofMark) on the official X account, November 13, 2026

“SBMM means you keep playing the same game against the same people (ie people who play the same way and the skill as you even if they are different players) so the games lack diversity especially when the constant challenge keeps players playing the meta instead of diversifying their load outs. You also never feel your self get better because the games are always the same difficulty. As you get better so does everyone in your lobbies.”

Read the original post on X ↗
“Ranked is a great place for SBMM but in pubs I'd rather play against a diversified lobby. Generally there will be some people better than you and some worse. And for me that is what made older CoDs more fun because SBMM was minimal.”
— Mark Rubin, former Call of Duty producer, in a post on X

Later in the thread, Rubin offered a concrete proposal: reward the lower-skill player who takes out a stronger opponent. “Something I wanted to do is reward players differently based on skill. If you're lower skilled and kill a better player you should get rewarded for that,” he wrote.

It is worth calibrating how much the statement matters: Rubin left the franchise years ago and does not speak for Infinity Ward. The post is a design opinion, not the announcement of a change — and, as of publication, the studio has not indicated it will alter the system because of it.

Classic, Open and what Modern Warfare 4 actually uses

The current argument is less about whether SBMM exists and more about how much weight skill should carry. Over the past two years, the franchise tested both extremes:

When What changed
2007Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare already considered skill in matchmaking, according to Activision
2019Modern Warfare popularizes the debate over stricter SBMM
2025Black Ops 7 debuts Open Matchmaking, with a much lighter skill weight
July 2026Black Ops 7 Season 5 introduces Classic Matchmaking in three playlists
October 23, 2026Modern Warfare 4 launches with Classic Matchmaking in every mode and no open playlist
November 13, 2026Mark Rubin publicly criticizes the system

Classic Matchmaking was announced as an homage to the early Black Ops games, with less weight on skill and more variety in public lobbies. In practice, part of the player base began reporting tougher matches — and Infinity Ward kept the system in Modern Warfare 4, citing internal data on retention, queue times and quit rates.

Official Modern Warfare 4 artwork about multiplayer maps and modes
Official launch artwork for Modern Warfare 4 focused on maps and modes: playlist variety is one of the factors that shape matchmaking. (Image: Courtesy of Activision)

Asked whether matchmaking could be “perfected,” multiplayer creative director Joe Cecot was blunt with IGN:

“I don't know if there's perfecting it. For us, I think the most important thing when we look at matchmaking is that the matches we put together are good matches. […] Though we're not talking about exact specifics on matchmaking, our end goal is that every match is a good match.”
— Joe Cecot, Modern Warfare 4 multiplayer creative director, to IGN

Infinity Ward co-studio head Mark Grigsby, meanwhile, shut the topic down in September: all the matchmaking information available is what has already been published on the official Call of Duty account. That stance contrasts with Rubin's and helps explain why the argument never dies: the details remain opaque.

A community test adds another layer. YouTuber TheXclusiveAce reported that some modes listed under “Popular” in Modern Warfare 4 appear to use a more permissive matchmaking system, with persistent lobbies, even without that label. The observation has not been confirmed by Infinity Ward and should be treated as an indication, not a rule. For the full picture of the game, the Modern Warfare 4 buying guide covers campaign, multiplayer and progression.

How to tell whether the problem is SBMM, ping or your team

Before blaming matchmaking, separate three symptoms that blur together mid-match:

Simple tests help with the diagnosis: switch playlists, compare times of day, play in a party and check your connection over cable. Network performance also depends on your PC — the Modern Warfare 4 PC requirements and 60 fps tips cover the settings that most affect smoothness.

At launch, there is no official way to turn SBMM off in Modern Warfare 4. Trying to “trick” the system is not worth it either: reverse boosting can send accounts to Limited Matchmaking lobbies and trigger temporary or permanent penalties, according to the franchise's rules.

What happens next

Ranked Play, which in Rubin's view is the natural home for SBMM, was not available when Modern Warfare 4 launched, and Infinity Ward has not confirmed a date. The community expects it in a future season, with a visible rank and its own rules — a system separate from public matchmaking.

In the meantime, the developer's defense rests on numbers. After Black Ops 7 Season 5, the company said quit rates fell across every skill group, with a 41% drop for more than half of players, and that search times improved. Critics counter that quitting a match also depends on repeated maps, progression and wanting to switch modes — factors aggregated data does not isolate.

Quick questions

How long has SBMM existed in Call of Duty? Activision says skill has been considered in matchmaking since Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare, in 2007. What changed over the years is how much weight it carries.

Is SBMM the same as Ranked Play? No. Ranked uses visible divisions and competitive rules. SBMM is the hidden calculation that also organizes public matches.

Why does my lobby get harder after a good match? Because your internal rating rises when you perform well, and the system starts looking for opponents in that new band. It is not a punishment: it is how a rating works.

Can I play without SBMM in Modern Warfare 4? Not through an official option. The game launched with Classic Matchmaking in every multiplayer mode, and the return of Open Matchmaking has not been confirmed.

The debate, then, is not about abolishing or keeping skill-based matchmaking, but about calibration: how much skill, how much connection and how much variety each playlist should accept. It is a design decision — and, as the franchise's last two years show, one the community watches closely every season.

Send a correction for this article

What is SBMM and how Call of Duty builds matches

The message will be sent to the newsroom for review. Privacy Policy.